Tropospheric
Scatter
Communications
Systems
Technical Report APA-TR-2010-0801
|
by
Dr
Carlo
Kopp, AFAIAA,
SMIEEE,
PEng
August,
2010
Updated April, 2012
Text
©
2010
- 2012 Carlo
Kopp
|
PLA CETC TS-504 tactical digital troposcatter
communication system on parade in 2009. This system has been deployed
extensively to support HQ-9 and S-300PMU2 mobile SAM batteries,
providing digital connectivity to the fixed IADS C3 network. Range and
datarate performance have not been disclosed to date (image Chinese
internet).
|
|
|
Background
FS-1037C Definition: “tropospheric
scatter: 1. The propagation of radio waves by scattering as a
result of irregularities or discontinuities in the physical properties
of the troposphere. [NTIA] [RR] [JP1] 2. A method of transhorizon
communications using frequencies from approximately 350 MHz to
approximately 8400 MHz. (188) Note: The propagation mechanism
is still not fully understood, though it includes several
distinguishable but changeable mechanisms such as propagation by means
of random reflections and scattering from irregularities in the
dielectric gradient density of the troposphere, smooth-Earth
diffraction, and diffraction over isolated obstacles (knife-edge
diffraction). Synonym troposcatter.”
Troposcatter versus conventional
line-of-sight microwave relay communications (US Army).
Troposcatter communications systems emerged
during the 1950s, during the period of intensive strategic competition
between the NATO nations and the Warsaw Pact, prior to the advent of
satellite communications. Such systems were extensively deployed by the
US and the Soviets, and to a lesser extent by their respective allies,
to provide C3 channels typically in sparsely populated areas. The
Soviets deployed an extensive network of troposcatter relays through
northern Siberia and the Far East, while the US deployed an extensive
network along the DEW lines, and through Alaska and the Aleutians.
These fixed networks were later supplemented by mobile tactical
systems, intended to provide digital trunk communications for manoeuvre
land force elements.
In technological terms, troposcatter communications are an offshoot of
early radar technology, and such systems were constructed using
elements of the same technology base, but also exploiting initially
technology used in period analogue telephony, and later digital
telephony.
The physics underpinning troposcatter communications are most
interesting, and remain the subject of academic research despite the
decline of troposcatter networks, mostly replaced by satellite
communications links.
In a conventional microwave relay communications network, a transmitter
must have a direct line of sight to a receiver. Modulated
radio-frequency power emitted by the transmitting antenna propagates,
with diminishing amplitude following the inverse square law Friis
equation, until it impinges on the receiving antenna, where it produces
an electrical signal which is amplified and demodulated by the receiver
equipment. While refraction due to the gradient in atmospheric
refractivity (due to density lapse rate with increasing altitude) can
“bend the beam” over the horizon slightly, typically this cannot
increase range beyond the line of sight (BLOS) to any significant
extent.
In a troposcatter system, the beam is bounced off the upper
troposphere, providing a true BLOS point to point communications
capability. These systems rely on the irregularity of the
refractivity gradient at such altitudes, resulting in impinging
microwave power being scattered forward in an irregular fashion.
In terms of achievable range performance, smaller troposcatter systems
are able to repeatably achieve 100 - 150 km ranges between a pair of
stations. Larger systems, with 10+ metre antenna diameters and kiloWatt
class transmit powers levels, have been reported with ranges of up to
400 km between a pair of stations. It is this range performance which
has underpinned the popularity of troposcatter technology for use in
undeveloped or underdeveloped regions, as it permits operation of a
microwave channel in terrain where the cost of both deploying and
maintaining a conventional microwave relay would be prohibitive. In
land warfare contingencies, troposcatter stations deployed by an
advancing manoeuvre force permit the maintenance of a chain of relays
back to the initial staging area, providing voice and data
connectivity, with no dependency on airborne or satellite relays.
Achievable channel capacity and thus data rates for troposcatter
systems are quite poor in comparison with direct line of sight (LOS)
microwave systems operating in the same bands, such as links between
aircraft and ground stations. This is for two basic reasons. The first
is because the forward scattered power levels are relatively low,
compared to inverse square law power levels across the same pathlength
in a direct LOS link. The second reason is a byproduct of the
irregularities in the scattering mechanisms, and variations in
pathlength arising from the propagation path, both resulting in a
strongly dispersive propagation medium. As with all dispersive media,
this impairs achievable bandwidth for most conventional signal
modulation schemes. Where performance data has been published for
troposcatter systems, there is a pronounced reduction in achievable
data rates with increasing link range, due to the cumulative effects of
dispersion and declining power at the receiver. Multipath fading
effects due to ground bounce at the receiver will also not contribute
to achievable channel capacity.
A range of design techniques have been adopted since the introduction
of this technology, to reduce the adverse impact of the medium. These
include frequency diversity, including the use of adaptive techniques,
but also more recently modulation techniques which are better suited to
dispersive media have been used, in addition to robust Forward Error
Control (FEC) techniques. Recent research suggests that newer
modulation techniques, including Coherent Orthogonal Frequency Division
Multiplexing (COFDM/OFDM), which is highly resistant to multipath
effects, are well suited to such an application (Hu et al).
Current state-of-the-art US equipment provides data rates of 8 - 22
Megabits/s at unspecified ranges, operating in the 1.7 - 2.3 GHz and
4.4 - 5 GHz bands, and using conventional Quadrature Phase Shift Keying
(QPSK) and FEC techniques, with quad frequency diversity. An example is
the US designed and built Comtech troposcatter component of the British
Cormorant battlefield network, cited at a data rate of 8 Megabits/s to
a range of up to 300 km.
While troposcatter systems no longer
occupy the prominent position they did during the early Cold War
period, being used primarily in niche applications, this technology may
yet see a revival as orbital and spectral congestion place increasing
constraints on satellite systems. With Moore's Law providing ever
cheaper computational power over time, the cost penalties of using
modulation and coding techniques capable of overcoming highly
dispersive and time variant propagation media will decline. Whether
this results in a major renaissance for troposcatter remains to be
seen.
|
Soviet /
Russian Troposcatter Systems
|
MNIRTI
Troposcatter Systems
|
Тип тропосферной станции
Troposcatter System Type
|
Год разработки
Year of IOC
|
Технические характеристики
Technical Characteristics
|
рабочий диапазон*
Operating
Band
|
кол-во каналов ТЧ
Number of Channels
|
Скорость передачи, кбит/с
Data Rate [kbps]
|
протяженность интервала, км
Range [km]
|
Р-408
|
1962 |
ДМ |
6 |
|
120 |
Р-408М |
1964 |
ДМ |
12 |
|
150 |
Р-410 |
1967 |
ДМ |
12…24 |
|
160 |
Р-410-7,5 |
1968 |
ДМ |
12…24 |
|
150 |
Р-410-5,5 |
1971 |
ДМ |
12…24 |
|
130 |
Р-420 |
1975 |
ДМ |
12 |
|
350 |
Р-417
|
1980 |
СМ |
60 |
480 |
200 |
Р-423-1 |
1981 |
СМ |
|
до 2 048 |
150 |
Р-444 |
1981 |
СМ |
|
до 2 х 480 |
150 |
Р-444-7,5 |
1984 |
СМ |
|
до 2 х 480 |
350 |
Р-417С
|
1984 |
СМ |
60…120 |
480 |
200 |
Р-423-1КФ |
1993 |
СМ |
|
2 048 |
150 |
*
сокращения в таблице: ДМ - дециметровый, СМ - сантиметровый |
Source:
V.V. Serov, A.M. Sechenikh, MNIRTI Troposcatter Systems, Informost
Journal, No.4 2006.
|
|
MNIRTI R-423-1 Brig-1/R-423-2A
Brig-2A/R-423-1KF
Ukrainian built MNIRTI R-423-1 Brig-1 troposcatter
system (Ukrspetsexport).
MNIRTI developed and then in 1981 deployed
the R-423-1 Brig-1 centimetric band mobile tactical troposcatter
system.
The system provides a 2048 kilobits/s capability to 150 km range, or a
64 kilobit/s capability to 230 km range. The system operates in two
S-band frequency ranges at 4.435 - 4.555 GHz and 4.630 - 4.750
GHz, using 220 subchannels, with H-pol., at a transmitter output of 1.5
kiloWatts. Digital interfaces are provided at 48 kilobits/s, 480
kilobits/s and 2048 kilobits/s.
The most recent variant is the R-423-2A intended as a replacement for
the R-412 Torf troposcatter system. The -2A operates in the same bands
as the -1 variant. Cited transmitter power is 220 Watts, and receiver
NF at 7 dB. The system is deployed on a KAMAZ-4310 truck, using a towed
2х8-Т400-1ВПС electrical generator.
Cited data rate and range performance figures for the R-423-2A are full
duplex 230 km at 1.2 kilobits/s, 210 km at 2.4 kilobits/s, 190 km at
4.8 kilobits/s, 170 km at 9.6 kilobits/s, 130 km at 48 kilobits/s, 90
km at 240 kilobits/s, and half duplex 140 km at 480 kilobits/s.
The R-423-1 series remains in production in
the Ukraine and is offered for export, in mobile and static relocatable
configurations.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Above: 1980s built R-423-1
Brig-1 tactical troposcatter system on the Ural 375D 6 x 6 truck, with
the power generator and support equipment carried by a KAMAZ-4310 truck
which is not depicted.
Left: a contemporary R-423AMK shelter mounted relocatable tactical
troposcatter system.
|
|
|
MNIRTI R-444 Eshelon / R-444-7,5 Eshelon D
|
|
The R-444 Eshelon and
R-444-7,5 Echelon D UHF band digital troposcatter relay stations were
developed and deployed between 1981 and 1984.
These designs provide 1 Megabit/s capability to 130 - 150 km, or 48
kilobits/s to 230 km.
|
|
MNIRTI R-420
Atlet-D
|
|
MNIRTI developed the R-420
Atlet D series in 1975 as a replacement for the widely used R-408 and
R-410 systems, retaining the same parabolic antenna configuration.
The station electronics were significantly improved in comparison with
the 1960s designs.
The R-420 receiver NF was improved by 3 dB, phaselocked oscillators
were employed to drive the demodulators, and polarisation diversity was
employed to improve performance.
The system employed paired Atlet AS-16 16 metre diameter antennas
providing a 35 dB gain.
Range per relay hop was improved to 350 to 400 km.
|
|
MNIRTI R-417S Baget S/R-417 Baget
|
|
The P-417 Baget 1 digital
relay system was deployed in 1980, after protracted research which
began in 1966.
The system provides either 60 digital voice channels, or 480
kilobits/sec of data.
|
To improve performance the design employs 16
channel frequency
diversity. Range per hop in a relay was 200 km, with up to 10 hops
permitted for a relay chain length of 2,000 km.
The static R-417S variant formed the backbone of the Warsaw Pact “Bars”
(Leopard) troposcatter relay network, comprising no less than 26 sites,
with 54 R-417S relay stations and an aggregate span distance of ~5,000
km. Two “Bars” spans employed the longer ranging R-420S systems. The
network, which spanned the territories of the USSR, Poland, East
Germany, Czechoslovakia, Hungary and Bulgaria, was commissioned in 1987
and fell into disuse three years later with the collapse of the Soviet
regime.
Further material on the Warsaw Pact “Bars” troposcatter network can be
found at: http://rammstein.dfmk.hu/~s200/tropo.html
|
NPP
Radiosvyaz
R-412A/B/F/S
TORF
An R-412A Torf-A tactical
troposcatter relay of the DDR NVA on a Ural-375 truck.
The R-412 Torf was developed as a
centimetric band mobile tactical troposcatter system, in four distinct
variants, to provide a point-to-point or relay capability over ranges
of 150 to 560 km:
- R-412A Torf-A army level mobile tactical troposcatter
system on the Ural 375 6 x 6 truck;
- R-412B Torf-B divisional level mobile tactical troposcatter
system on the MTLB tracked vehicle, with power provided by a
ГАБ-8-Т/230 generator driven by a PTO;
- R-412F Torf-F front (corps) level mobile tactical
troposcatter system on the Ural 375 6 x 6 truck, including a Sosna-M
microwave relay on a ZIL-131 truck;
- R-412S Torf-S static variant for fixed site applications,
based on the R-412F, but using a 20 metre Sosna-18S mast system.
The system transmits at 200 Watts or 400 Watts in the S-band. Frequency
diversity is employed, with subchannels spaced at 192 MHz. Cited data
rates are 1.2, 4.8, 12 or 48 kiloBaud.
A Russian Army R-412A Torf-A
tactical troposcatter relay carried on a KAMAZ-4310.
|
MNIRTI R-410/R-410-5,5/R-410-7,5
Atlet / Albatros
A disused R-410 relay system
antenna installation in the Amur region (via Russian internet).
|
|
The R-410 supplanted the
R-408 series in production, from 1967.
It was built in three main variants with 5.5 metre, 7.5 metre and 10
metre diameter parabolic antennas.
Range varied between 150 and 250 km, and a relay system could be
constructed with up to 10 hops.
The system provided 24 full duplex analogue telephone voice channels.
|
|
MNIRTI R-408/R-408M Baklan
A disused and decaying R-408 system
antenna installation in Russia (via Russian internet).
|
|
The UHF-band R-408 Baklan
(Cormorant) was developed in 1962 by MNIRTI to provide a static
multihop troposcatter relay capability for use in sparsely populated
areas.
The designed was enhanced in 1964 and continued in production as the
R-408M. The R-408 is readily identified by the 10 metre parabolic
antenna
diameter.
|
The system delivered a range of 120 - 150 km
between stations. The R-408 provided 12 analogue telephone channels
using Frequency Division Multiplexing.
A disused and decaying R-408 system
antenna installation in Russia (via Russian internet).
|
|
PLA
Troposcatter
Systems
CETC TS-504
Troposcatter Communication System
Deployed TS-504 antenna system
(image Chinese internet).
The CETC technical brochure for the TS-504
states no more than the obvious, which is that the system is a Chinese
analogue to the Soviet R-423 series. The system was prominently
displayed during the 2009 military parade, and is known to have been
exported to Pakistan.
The TS-504 is frequently employed to provide digital IADS connectivity
to mobile HQ-9 and S-300PMU2 / SA-20B SAM batteries.
Some claims have emerged that the PLA's troposcatter systems were
supplied by the Ukraine. The distinctly different antenna designs on
the Ukrainian R-423-1 variants and TS-504 would suggest otherwise.
Chinese researchers have published a respectable number of research
journal
publications on troposcatter communications, including papers
describing the use of relatively advanced modulation techniques.
Stowed TS-504 (image
Chinese internet).
Detail of stowed TS-504 antenna suite (image
Chinese internet).
The PLA have used the TS-504
extensively to support high mobility S-300PMU2 Favorit / SA-20B
Gargoyle and HQ-9 SAM batteries with IADS connectivity. Depicted a 96L6
radar, 5P85TE2 TEL with a BAZ-69022 tractor, and a TS-504. Datalink
interfaces between these systems have not been disclosed to date
(Chinese internet).
|
CETC
TS-510/GS-510
Troposcatter
Communication
System
|
|
The CETC TS-510 / GS-510
Troposcatter Communication System is a short range tactical design
which is available in a static relocatable GS-510 variant, and a fully
mobile TS-510 variant.
To date no official figures have been released detailing range and data
rate performance.
|
|
|
Western
Troposcatter
Systems
|
AN/TRC-170
Tropospheric Scatter Microwave Radio Terminal
AN/TRC-170 (US DoD).
Variants of the AN/TRC-170 have been the
primary tactical troposcatter system used by US forces for two decades.
The system has proven highly effective in supporting ground force
manoeuvre elements in conflicts since 1990. The system is now
considered legacy equipment, but continues in operation with block
upgrades applied. The performance of the system is cited at data rates
of 4 Megabits/s up to 16 Megabits/s with an upgrade kit installed.
|
AN/GRC-201 /
AN/TRC-97 Troposcatter Communication System
The AN/GRC-201 / AN/TRC-97 systems were
replaced by variants of the AN/TRC-170.
|
|
-
V.V. Serov, A.M. Sechenikh,
MNIRTI Troposcatter
Systems, Informost
Journal, No.4 2006.
-
-
-
-
Hu Maokai, Chen
Xihong Shu, Tao Dong Shaoqiang (Missile Inst., AFEU,
Sanyuan, China), New generation troposcatter communication based on
OFDM modulation, 9th International Conference on Electronic
Measurement
&
Instruments,
2009.
ICEMI '09, 16-19 Aug. 2009, URL: http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpl/mostRecentIssue.jsp?punumber=5235876
-
|
Technical
Report
APA-TR-2010-0801
|
|